Senate committee kills a bill to allow new trials based on new evidence of innocence

Let’s see what you remember from your high school civics class.

One thing everyone agrees about is that if a person has been convicted of a felony and evidence is found later that proves the person is innocent, the courts will order a new trial.

Right? Isn’t that what the criminal justice system does whenever it must right a wrong and free an innocent person? Isn’t that what happens in America?

Well, no. Not in Wyoming, at least.

In fact, there are several arbitrary rules here that can keep an innocent person in prison even if evidence to exonerate him comes to light. For instance, new evidence must be discovered within two years of the start of a person’s incarceration in order to qualify that person for a new trial.

“Right now we have an arbitrary and unjust time limit,” said Aaron Lytle, a Cheyenne attorney and member of the Rocky Mountain Innocence Project. “If [evidence] is found more than two years later, you’re just out of luck.”

Equally random is the state’s distinction between DNA- and non-DNA-based evidence. See, if new DNA evidence is discovered, it can be used to obtain a new trial regardless of how long it’s been since a person started serving time. But if that evidence is not DNA evidence, the two-year rule applies.

House Bill 144, sponsored by Rep. Charles Pelkey (D-Laramie) attempted to end that injustice.

HB-144 sailed past the House Minerals, Corporations and Economic Development Committee by a 9-0 vote, and the 60-person House passed the bill unanimously. Proposals with that much support in one chamber are typically granted at least the dignity of a vote in the other.

But on Monday, the Senate Judiciary Committee killed Pelkey’s bill. After taking about a half-hour of public comments—all but one person spoke in support of the bill—Sen. Dave Kinskey (R-Sheridan) made a motion to move the bill, but no one seconded it. Under legislative rules, that killed the bill for this session.


The committee decided to ask the Legislative Management Council to select “actual innocence”—the jargon term for this subject—as an interim study, part of a broader review of the criminal justice system that will take place after this legislative session. The problem with that idea is that lawmakers, judges, attorneys, prosecutors and law enforcement already did an interim study last year and couldn’t agree on a bill to recommend. So Pelkey, frustrated by previous efforts to convince his colleagues that this is a real problem in Wyoming, sponsored this bill himself.

Pelkey said he was surprised by the committee’s decision. “We get a unanimous vote in the House and all of a sudden we’re blindsided by the attorney general’s office that raised some concerns we didn’t even discuss during the interim last year,” he said.

Instead of passing a law that could correct injustices, taxpayers will foot the bill for another interim study that will gather dust on the shelves.


The single person to speak against HB-144 had enough heft to kill it: Chief Deputy Attorney General John G. Knepper.

The way Knepper portrayed it, the court system would be swamped by felons asking for new trials if HB-144 passed. “This is an exoneration process that’s available to anyone convicted of a felony,” he said. “Including people who have served their time, they’re back in society and want to press so they can have another trial.”

The lawyer seemed particularly upset that poor clients file their motions pro se and do not have to pay for it. “Pro se cases sort of tumble in on a regular basis,” he said. “We’d like to see some point where we can say, ‘OK, you’ve had your chance, but we’re done.’”

Knepper went on with a litany other complications he said would engulf the state’s legal system if the two-year ban were lifted for new non-DNA evidence. He dubiously argued that stakeholders had not been given enough notice of the committee meeting, claimed the issue had not received sufficient discussion despite the last interim study, and effectively browbeat the committee into doing his bidding.


Of course, Knepper’s concerns are far-fetched. Pelkey pointed out that other states with similar laws to the one he proposed have not been deluged by people seeking new trials. Lytle said Arkansas and Idaho are the only states that, like Wyoming, have a two-year limit to file a motion based on new evidence. The other 47 states get by just fine letting innocent people out of prison when new evidence arises after twenty-four months.

But the law could have helped real Wyomingites. DeWayne Spellers testified to the committee that he had been in a traffic accident in 1988 and the man who caused the crash fled on foot. When law enforcement officers investigated, however, they told Spellers they knew he was responsible for the accident.

He was convicted of attempting to obtain funds under false pretenses after he filed an insurance claim, which is a felony. He was sentenced to probation and completed his time, and got on with his life.

That is, until 16 years later, when the FBI and state investigators knocked on his door to ask him about the accident. A man in custody had confessed to a number of crimes, including the accident Spellers was convicted for. “An FBI agent told my lawyer while I was present that he had evidence that proved I’m innocent, but I never saw it. I don’t even know what it was.”

With the two-year statute of limitations on filing for a new trial, Spellers was frustrated. “I just want to clear my name,” he said. He applied for a pardon from then-Gov. Dave Freudenthal, who denied his request.

As he walked out of the committee room, others in the audience told Spellers they were sorry about what happened to him. He said he was disappointed when the bill was killed, but he’s not giving up. “I’ve been coming to hearings for years,” he said. “I’ll keep coming.”

Receive weekly email roundups of our Capitol Dispatches and other Better Wyoming communications by filling out the form on our homepage. You can also follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

SUGGESTED FOR YOU With the budget cut to its limit, the House turns to inanity and minutia as a means of filling its days with “serious debate” February 8, 2017 Many people can’t take time off from work to see what their state lawmakers are up to. Those who follow the news... In the face […]
51 replies
  1. Anderson Crummett
    Anderson Crummett says:

    I have really learned some new things from a blog post. Yet another thing to I have recognized is that usually, FSBO sellers can reject you actually. Remember, they can prefer never to use your products and services. But if you actually maintain a comfortable, professional partnership, offering assistance and keeping contact for four to five weeks, you will usually be capable of win a conversation. From there, a house listing follows. Thanks

  2. Jurassic Dildo
    Jurassic Dildo says:

    Thank you for publishing this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment. I subscribed to your blog and shared this on my Twitter. Thanks again for a great post!

  3. andy strutt
    andy strutt says:

    andrew david strutt DOB 6/3/1975 sprint phone 312-917-5986 google voice 702-514-0650 works at leidos cyber has raped 2 girls at defcon hacker conventions. astrutt wife Sichan Li is in the United States illegally. r0d3nt has an undiagnosed psychiatric disorder from a head injury. astrutt has taken money from Lebanse Intelligence Officer and recently arrested hacker and owner of Krypton Security Khalil Sehnaoui. r0d3nt accepted a hotel suite in Las Vegas in 2015, 2016, and 2017 in excess of $2,000 a night from Khalil Sehnaoui. andy strutt wife is a former reporter and Chinese Communist Party reporter. andy strutt wife has access to his secret material.

  4. How To Get Laid Online With No First Date
    How To Get Laid Online With No First Date says:

    I kind of agree with everything said here. There’s just one problem. It doesn’t talk about what’s the best site to join to get laid. That’s the most important part of it all. If you’re wanting to get laid, then this is the site for you You’re going to get some pussy there. Don’t beat off tonight. Get yourself some action. You can beat off tomorrow. Today is your day to get some pussy.

  5. Sexxx
    Sexxx says:

    Thanks for writing this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment. I subscribed to your blog and shared this on my Facebook. Thanks again for a great article!

  6. Bail Bondsman Tampa
    Bail Bondsman Tampa says:

    I loved as much as you’ll receive carriwd out right here.
    The sketch is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish.

    nonetheless, you command gett bought an nervousness over that you wish be
    deliverinhg the following. unwell unquestionably come further formery ahain since exactly
    the same nearly very often inside case you shield
    this hike.

  7. Titi
    Titi says:

    Thank you for writing this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment. I subscribed to your blog and shared this on my Facebook. Thanks again for a great article!

  8. kumpulan youtube terbaru
    kumpulan youtube terbaru says:

    I most certainly will immediately knowledge the rss as I can not in discovering ones electronic mail subscription web page link or even e-newsletter service. Conduct you have any? Be sure to let me personally know to ensure that I could merely sign up kumpulan youtube terbaru. Thanks a lot.

  9. Viral style
    Viral style says:

    cheers for dropping this story. I am definitely tired of struggling to find relevant and intelligent commentary on this subject. Everyone nowadays seem to go to extremes to either drive home their viewpoint or suggest that everybody else in the globe is wrong. cheers for your concise and relevant insight.
    Viral style

  10. rekomendasi saham
    rekomendasi saham says:

    Your post on Senate committee kills a bill to allow new trials based on new evidence of innocence – A Better Wyoming is great. We hope you can continue delivering many lot article . Long live

  11. fake eyelashes near me
    fake eyelashes near me says:

    Wow that was strange. I just wrote an extremely long comment but after I clicked submit
    my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways,
    just wanted to say superb blog!

  12. Sniper 3D jotnak
    Sniper 3D jotnak says:

    Thanks for publishing this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment. I subscribed to your blog and shared this on my Twitter. Thanks again for a great article!

  13. gift for her boots
    gift for her boots says:

    I feel this is among the so much significant info for me.
    And i’m satisfied studying your article. However should remark on some basic issues,
    The site taste is wonderful, the articles is in point of
    fact nice : D. Excellent process, cheers

  14. Eileen
    Eileen says:

    Hello, I thinhk your website might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look aat your website iin Firefox, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, terrific blog!

  15. eebest8 back
    eebest8 back says:

    “Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back often!”

  16. Make Money Promoting ClickBank
    Make Money Promoting ClickBank says:

    Did you know that people make their entire income promoting ClickBank? You too could be one of the many who have quit their job. Affiliate marketing is as old as the internet. It’s not going to go away any time soon. You too can get your piece of the pie. Why shouldn’t you? Do you really like working the job you have? Are you going to be able to do it until you retire? If you’re job requires physical labor, then you know the answer to that question. There’s no way you’re going to be able to do that when you get older. That’s just the truth and no one needs to tell it to you. Right now you could be making money online. Does it require work? You better believe it does. No honest person is ever going to tell you that it’s possible to become a millionaire online without doing any work whatsoever. It’s not possible. That doesn’t mean there isn’t money to be made. There’s plenty of money out there to be made by people just like yourself. Now you know there’s going to be a pitch for a product. You’re right about that. Click on the link and check it out. There’s a video you can watch that will explain everything. It will tell you how to make money using ClickBank. Watch the video and see what you think. You too can be one of the many who earn a living promoting ClickBank. Some people earn a good living and there’s no reason why you can’t.

  17. Magnolia
    Magnolia says:

    I’d like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this website.
    I am hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts by you later on as well.

    In truth, your creative writing abilities has inspired me to
    get my own, personal blog now 😉

  18. Make money with social media
    Make money with social media says:

    Are you the type who likes to hangout on social media? Have you ever thought about making it a career? You can help promote their business using social media. This means you can do what you already love doing and make money at it. Does this sound like something you’d like to do? If so, then check out You can help people and make some money in the process. You already hang out at social media sites. Why not make a few bucks doing it?

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. best essay writing service

    argumentative essay, best essay writing service, how to write an argumentative essay…

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.